See, this is a play worthy of being called one of the plays of the year. Going all out and extended into foul territory to make a helluva catch is legit; catching a ball in foul territory then running another ten feet and driving headfirst into the stands isn’t. I still say that Jeter catch is the most overrated of all time, just ahead of David Wright’s “diving” barehanded catch – he caught the ball over his shoulder then fell down, he didn’t dive.

This catch is better than both.